Comparison
ProtestMax vs Home Tax Shield
A yearly enrollment fee plus a cut of your savings.
Home Tax Shield
30%
of savings, every year
ProtestMax
$45
flat, one time
Cost Comparison
What You Actually Pay
Home Tax Shield charges 30% of your savings. ProtestMax is $45 flat no matter how much you save.
| Tax Reduction | Home Tax Shield Fee | ProtestMax Fee | You Save |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | $300 | $45 | $255 |
| $2,000 | $600 | $45 | $555 |
| $5,000 | $1,500 | $45 | $1,455 |
| $10,000 | $3,000 | $45 | $2,955 |
Feature by Feature
Full Comparison
| Feature | Home Tax Shield | ProtestMax |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | $30/yr enrollment + ~30% of savings | $45 flat |
| You keep | ~70% of savings (after the annual fee) | 100% of savings |
| See evidence before paying | Yes (Grade A-F) | |
| Auto-enrollment | Yes (annual $30 + contingency) | No recurring charges |
| Upfront cost | $30/yr | $45 |
| Who files | They file for you | You file (pre-filled forms) |
| Hearing representation | Yes (Texas) | No (hearing script included) |
| States covered | Texas | All 50 states |
Honest Take
When Home Tax Shield Makes Sense
- You want a low annual commitment and full-service filing in Texas.
- You prefer a firm to handle the protest and don’t mind the recurring enrollment fee.
- Your reduction is small enough that the $30 + 30% is still near $45.
Best For Most Homeowners
When ProtestMax Makes Sense
- You want to keep 100% of your tax savings.
- You want to see your evidence grade (A-F) before paying anything.
- You don’t want auto-enrollment surprises or recurring fees.
- You’re comfortable submitting pre-filled forms (~10 minutes).
Frequently Asked Questions
Home Tax Shield vs ProtestMax FAQ
How much does Home Tax Shield cost?
Home Tax Shield charges a roughly $30 annual enrollment fee plus about 30% of any tax savings they secure. ProtestMax is a one-time $45 with no recurring fee and you keep 100% of your savings.
Does Home Tax Shield auto-renew?
Yes — it operates on an annual enrollment that renews, charging the fee plus contingency each year. ProtestMax has no auto-enrollment; each protest is a one-time purchase.
Is ProtestMax a good Home Tax Shield alternative?
ProtestMax is a flat $45 with no annual fee and you keep all of your savings, versus Home Tax Shield’s $30/yr + ~30% contingency. The tradeoff: Home Tax Shield files for you; with ProtestMax you submit the pre-filled packet yourself.